In 2023, Magic: The Gathering released several new sets with diverse themes and mechanics. However, not all sets were well-received. March of the Machine Aftermath was criticized for its small size and lack of plot, as well as the introduction of expensive booster packs with few cards. Commander Masters faced backlash due to its high price and a mix of commonly reprinted cards alongside valuable ones. Phyrexia All Will Be One had divisive mechanics and aesthetics, with few powerful cards standing the test of time. March of the Machine was praised for its innovations, but criticized for its anticlimactic narrative. Lost Caverns of Ixalan faced issues with confusing mechanics, but was praised for its tribal set and powerful precon Commander decks. MTG Doctor Who was well-received for its thematic designs and unique themes, with a focus on interesting and creative deck building. Dominaria Remastered was a nostalgic mashup of cards from different Dominaria sets. Overall, 2023 had a mix of successful and unsuccessful MTG sets, with some facing criticism for their mechanics, aesthetics, and pricing.
Read Full Article
Ranking every Magic: The Gathering set of 2023
